Which is better and more accurate, a Geiger Counter, or a Scintillator?
Geiger counters are an indispensable tool for any scientist, professional or amateur (like me). The Geiger counter can detect radiation quickly and effectively. They are also relatively cheap, ranging from a few hundred to a few thousand dollars (most are under $1,000).
Geiger counters have varying abilities and detect different particles and energy levels of those particles with differing levels of efficiency. By far, beta radiation is detected the best with many tubes detecting 2 to 4 out of ten particles which hit them.
Alpha radiation is a bit lower, with many tubes totally blind to them and those which are not only detecting 5 to 10 particles per every 100. Gamma and X-ray radiation is the lowest for Geiger counters, where often between 1 and 3 photons are detected per 100.
A pancake style Geiger Counter is more sensitive than a tube type. A small tube Geiger Counter is less sensitive than a Geiger Counter with one or even two large tubes. If your interest is in detecting radiation down to the level of food contamination, you must purchase a pancake style detector, because the tube types are just not sensitive enough to pick up anything.
Pros -- Cheap, easy to use, portable, can detect alpha, beta, gamma, and x-ray.
Cons -- Cannot determine isotope (fact), cannot determine energies, very low gamma and x-ray efficiency.
Scintillation counters are the tools of the professional nuclear scientist. Scintillation counters exist for gamma, x-ray, beta, and alpha radiation (a specific unit for each). When used with a multi channel spectrum analyzer, the counter can identify isotopes by their energies.
Some Gamma spectrometers can even be used for complex gamma recoil analysis (mossbaur spectroscopy) which aid in determining the molecular bonds of various atoms, such as iron.
Crystal scintillators may cost a few hundred to a few thousand dollars, while a multi channel spectrum analyzer to attach to one is at least a few thousand more. This means an entry level lab-grade unit (like mine) will set you back about $5000.
Very powerful soil state units, like those used at universities, can be well beyond $10,000 and even as much as a million dollars. A good High Purity Germanium (HPGe) is at least $10k. These detectors may be used without a multi channel spectrum analyzer, but they only count at that point. Hobbyists have created multi channel spectrum analyzer's for under $1,000 dollars.
Pros -- Can identify isotopes, measures energies, very sensitive to gamma rays (for gamma sicntillators), can probe hyperfine molecular bonds.
Cons -- Expensive ($1000 and up), complex, requires extensive skill (physics), portable units are often very expensive. Thanks to http://Anti-Proton.com
Wikipedia; "A scintillation counter is an instrument for detecting and measuring ionizing radiation.
It consists of a scintillator which generates photons of light in response to incident radiation, a sensitivephotomultiplier tube which converts the light to an electrical signal, and the necessary electronics to process the photomultiplier tube output.
Scintillation counters are widely used because they can be made inexpensively yet with good quantum efficiency and can measure both the intensity and the energy of incident radiation.
Operation
When a charged particle strikes the scintillator, its atoms are excited and photons are emitted. These are directed at the photomultiplier tube's photocathode, which emits electrons by the photoelectric effect. These electrons are electrostatically accelerated and focused by an electrical potential so that they strike the first dynode of the tube. The impact of a single electron on the dynode releases a number of secondary electrons which are in turn accelerated to strike the second dynode. Each subsequent dynode impact releases further electrons, and so there is a current amplifying effect at each dynode stage. Each stage is at a higher potential than the previous to provide the accelerating field. The resultant output signal at the anode is in the form of a measurable pulse for each photon detected at the photocathode, and is passed to the processing electronics. The pulse carries information about the energy of the original incident radiation on the scintillator. Thus both intensity and energy of the radiation can be measured.
The scintillator must be in complete darkness so that visible light photons do not swamp the individual photon events caused by incident ionising radiation. To achieve this a thin opaque foil, such as aluminised mylar, is often used, though it must have a low enough mass to prevent undue attenuation of the incident radiation being measured.
The article on the photomultiplier tube carries a detailed description of the tube's operation.
Detection materials
The scintillator consists of a transparent crystal, usually a phosphor, plastic (usually containing anthracene) or organic liquid (see liquid scintillation counting) that fluoresces when struck by ionizing radiation.
Cesium iodide (CsI) in crystalline form is used as the scintillator for the detection of protons and alpha particles. sodium iodide (NaI) containing a small amount of thallium is used as a scintillator for the detection of gamma waves and Zinc Sulphide is widely used as a detector of alpha particles.
Detector efficiencies
See also: Counting efficiency
Gamma
The quantum efficiency of a gamma-ray detector (per unit volume) depends upon the density of electrons in the detector, and certain scintillating materials, such as sodium iodide and bismuth germanate, achieve high electron densities as a result of the high atomic numbers of some of the elements of which they are composed. However, detectors based on semiconductors, notably hyperpure germanium, have better intrinsic energy resolution than scintillators, and are preferred where feasible for gamma-ray spectrometry.
Neutron
In the case of neutron detectors, high efficiency is gained through the use of scintillating materials rich in hydrogen that scatter neutrons efficiently.Liquid scintillation counters are an efficient and practical means of quantifying beta radiation.
Applications
Scintillation counters are used to measure radiation in a variety of applications.
- Hand held radiation survey meters
- Personnel and environmental monitoring for Radioactive contamination
- Medical imaging
- National and homeland security
- Border security
- Nuclear plant safety
- Radon levels in water
- Oil Well logging
Several products have been introduced in the market utilising scintillation counters for detection of potentially dangerous gamma-emitting materials during transport. These include scintillation counters designed for freight terminals, border security, ports, weigh bridge applications, scrap metal yards and contamination monitoring of nuclear waste. There are variants of scintillation counters mounted on pick-up trucks and helicopters for rapid response in case of a security situation due to dirty bombs or radioactive waste.[1][2] Hand-held units are also commonly used.[3]
Guidance on application use
In the United Kingdom the HSE has issued a user guidance note on selecting the correct radiation measurement instrument for the application concerned [1]. This covers all radiation instrument technologies, and is a useful comparative guide to the use of scintillation detectors.
Alpha and Beta contamination detection
Industrial radioactive contamination monitors, either hand-held or installed require a large detection area to ensure efficient and rapid coverage of monitored surfaces. For this the scintillation counter with a large area scintillator window and integrated photomultiplier tube is ideally suited and finds wide application in the field of radioactive contamination monitoring of personnel and the environment. Detectors are designed to have one or two scintillation materials, depending on the application. "Single phosphor" detectors are used for either alpha or beta, and "Dual phosphor" detectors are used to detect both.
A scintillator such as zinc sulphide is used for alpha particle detection, whilst plastic scintillators are used for beta detection. The resultant scintillation energies can be discriminated so that alpha and beta counts can be measured separately with the same detector. This technique is used in both hand-held and fixed monitoring equipment, and such instruments are relatively inexpensive compared with the gas proportional detector.
Scintillation counter as a spectrometer
Scintillators often convert a single photon of high energy radiation into high number of lower-energy photons, where the number of photons per megaelectronvolt of input energy is fairly constant. By measuring the intensity of the flash (the number of the photons produced by the x-ray or gamma photon) it is therefore possible to discern the original photon's energy.
The spectrometer consists of a suitable scintillator crystal, a photomultiplier tube, and a circuit for measuring the height of the pulses produced by the photomultiplier. The pulses are counted and sorted by their height, producing a x-y plot of scintillator flash brightness vs number of the flashes, which approximates the energy spectrum of the incident radiation, with some additional artifacts. A monochromatic gamma radiation produces a photopeak at its energy. The detector also shows response at the lower energies, caused by Compton scattering, two smaller escape peaks at energies 0.511 and 1.022 MeV below the photopeak for the creation of electron-positron pairs when one or both annihilation photons escape, and a backscatter peak. Higher energies can be measured when two or more photons strike the detector almost simultaneously (pile-up, within the time resolution of the data acquisition chain), appearing as sum peaks with energies up to the value of two or more photopeaks added.[4]
History
The modern electronic scintillation counter was invented in 1944 by Sir Samuel Curran[5][6] whilst he was working on the Manhattan Project at the University of California at Berkeley, and it is based on the work of earlier researchers reaching back to Antoine Henri Becquerel, who is generally credited with discovering radioactivity, whilst working on thephosphorescence of certain uranium salts (in 1896). The Spinthariscope was an early method of detecting the scintillation events by eye."
END
What Is A Scintillation Counter And How Does It Work? via @AGreenRoad
For more articles and videos like this;
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/low-level-nuclear-radiation-in-food-and.html
A GREEN ROAD PROJECT INDEX
Table Of Contents
http://tinyurl.com/agrindex
2,000 + Videos And Articles
A Green Road Project - Detailing The Science Of Sustainable Health and Success. What benefits seven future generations, and causes no harm?
Access 1,800 + videos plus articles by clicking on the Pages link in left upper corner, or type in your search words in search box at top right side corner, at;
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/?view=magazine
AGreenRoad Project YouTube Video Channel (1,000 + Videos)
http://www.youtube.com/channel/UCnFqw1KdmG3OUUwfu2bt3yQ/videos?view=1
Or http://tinyurl.com/agryoutube
Index/Table Of Contents http://tinyurl.com/agrindex
A Green Road Project - Detailing The Science Of Sustainable Health and Success. What benefits seven future generations, and causes no harm?
Access 1,800 + videos plus articles by clicking on the Pages link in left upper corner, or type in your search words in search box at top right side corner, at;
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/?view=magazine
AGreenRoad Project YouTube Video Channel (1,000 + Videos)
http://www.youtube.com/channel/UCnFqw1KdmG3OUUwfu2bt3yQ/videos?view=1
Or http://tinyurl.com/agryoutube
Index/Table Of Contents http://tinyurl.com/agrindex
About A Green Road Project...
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/green-road-blog-home-page.html
Or http://tinyurl.com/agrabout
911 Planet Earth Emergency
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/why-all-nuclear-plants-must-be-shut-down.html
Spiritual, Interfaith, Consciousness; How To Create Heaven On Earth
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/spiritualinterfaithconsciousness.html
Or http://tinyurl.com/agrspirit
Holistic Living And Green Energy
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/green-energy-green-living.htmlOr http://tinyurl.com/agrgreen
Exploring the Inner and Outer Mysteries of Life
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/mystery.html
Or http://tinyurl.com/agrmys
Peace, War, Human Rights, Justice, Prisons
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/human-rightsjusticeprisons.html
Drugs, Medicine and GMO's
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/natural-health-drugs-medicine.html
Global Corporations And The 1%; Art And Science Of Deception
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/corporations-art-and-science-of.html
Nuclear Accidents, Recycling Nuclear Weapons/Fuel
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/nuclear-accidents-around-world.html
Individual Radioactive Elements/Isotopes, USA Radiation Exposure Prevention and Reversal, Music
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/individual-radioactive-elementsisotopes.html
Low Dose Radiation Dangers/Symptoms For Children And Adults
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/low-dose-radiation-dangers-for-children.html
Uranium Mining and Enrichment - Nuclear Bomb -Nuclear Fuel Manufacturing
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/uranium-mining-and-enrichment.html
Low Level Nuclear Radiation In Food And Water, Geiger Counters
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/low-level-nuclear-radiation-in-food-and.html
Effects Of Internal Low Level Nuclear Radiation
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/effects-of-internal-low-level-nuclear.html
Animals and Low Level Radiation Effects
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/animals-and-low-level-radiation-effects.html
Nuclear Reactor Recertification
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/nuclear-reactor-recertification.html
Long Term Storage Of Nuclear Fuel, Nuclear Waste
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/recycling-or-long-term-storage-of.html
What is Needed? Top Down Champions Of Sustainability With $; via @AGreenRoad
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/2013/06/what-is-needed-top-down-champions-of.html
"Do not go where the freeway may lead - Go instead where there is no path and leave A Green Road for others to follow."
…………………………………………………………………………………
About A Green Road Project...
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/green-road-blog-home-page.html
Or http://tinyurl.com/agrabout
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/green-road-blog-home-page.html
Or http://tinyurl.com/agrabout
911 Planet Earth Emergency
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/why-all-nuclear-plants-must-be-shut-down.html
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/why-all-nuclear-plants-must-be-shut-down.html
Spiritual, Interfaith, Consciousness; How To Create Heaven On Earth
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/spiritualinterfaithconsciousness.html
Or http://tinyurl.com/agrspirit
Holistic Living And Green Energy
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/green-energy-green-living.html
Or http://tinyurl.com/agrgreen
Exploring the Inner and Outer Mysteries of Life
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/mystery.html
Or http://tinyurl.com/agrmys
Exploring the Inner and Outer Mysteries of Life
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/mystery.html
Or http://tinyurl.com/agrmys
Peace, War, Human Rights, Justice, Prisons
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/human-rightsjusticeprisons.html
Drugs, Medicine and GMO's
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/natural-health-drugs-medicine.html
Global Corporations And The 1%; Art And Science Of Deception
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/corporations-art-and-science-of.html
Nuclear Accidents, Recycling Nuclear Weapons/Fuel
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/nuclear-accidents-around-world.html
Individual Radioactive Elements/Isotopes, USA Radiation Exposure Prevention and Reversal, Music
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/individual-radioactive-elementsisotopes.html
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/individual-radioactive-elementsisotopes.html
Low Dose Radiation Dangers/Symptoms For Children And Adults
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/low-dose-radiation-dangers-for-children.html
Uranium Mining and Enrichment - Nuclear Bomb -Nuclear Fuel Manufacturing
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/uranium-mining-and-enrichment.html
Low Level Nuclear Radiation In Food And Water, Geiger Counters
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/low-level-nuclear-radiation-in-food-and.html
Effects Of Internal Low Level Nuclear Radiation
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/effects-of-internal-low-level-nuclear.html
Animals and Low Level Radiation Effects
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/animals-and-low-level-radiation-effects.html
Nuclear Reactor Recertification
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/nuclear-reactor-recertification.html
Long Term Storage Of Nuclear Fuel, Nuclear Waste
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/p/recycling-or-long-term-storage-of.html
What is Needed? Top Down Champions Of Sustainability With $; via @AGreenRoad
http://agreenroad.blogspot.com/2013/06/what-is-needed-top-down-champions-of.html
"Do not go where the freeway may lead - Go instead where there is no path and leave A Green Road for others to follow."
…………………………………………………………………………………
Social Media Links
Share these links above by copying and pasting them into email, Facebook and Twitter, or click on the share buttons below each article/video. Thanks for doing your part. Keep shining your light and sharing this information with friends, co-workers, politicians, doctors, professors, and other leaders!
As the Dalai Lama says; “Never give up, never.” Every person is important.
Follow A Green Road Project on Twitter 50,000 + followers https://twitter.com/agreenroad
'Join' A Green Road Project Facebook Group, and add your friends too! http://www.facebook.com/groups/agreenroad/
A Green Road Project YouTube Channel playlist of 700 videos in many categories at;Or, type in "A Green Road" in the www.Youtube.com search box to see videos available. You will be able to browse one of the largest selections of creative commons licensed videos available on Youtube.
LinkedIn Professionals Network A Green Road Projecthttp://www.linkedin.com/in/agreenroad
Vote For A Green Road Project – help make this a popular website http://www.mywot.com/en/scorecard/www.agreenroadblog.com
Join A Green Road Discussion Group 45,000 + members http://www.care2.com/c2c/group/agreenroad
Add Us On Google+
google.com/+AGreenRoadProjectUSABest of A Green Road Project On Google Plus
Add A Green Road Project RSS News Feed to your website, blog or news servicehttp://feeds.feedburner.com/AGreenRoadBlog
What is your score? AGreenRoad Project has a Klout score of 50+ http://klout.com/#/AGreenRoad
Network on MerchantCircle http://member.merchantcircle.com/agreenroad
Read A Green Road Project Feed Burner Syndication FeedBurner makes it easy to receive content updates in My Yahoo!, Newsgator, Bloglines, and other news readers
A Green Road Project Events; http://www.eventbrite.com/myprofile/?oid=4777791053..
Share these links above by copying and pasting them into email, Facebook and Twitter, or click on the share buttons below each article/video. Thanks for doing your part. Keep shining your light and sharing this information with friends, co-workers, politicians, doctors, professors, and other leaders!
As the Dalai Lama says; “Never give up, never.” Every person is important.
Follow A Green Road Project on Twitter 50,000 + followers https://twitter.com/agreenroad
'Join' A Green Road Project Facebook Group, and add your friends too! http://www.facebook.com/groups/agreenroad/
A Green Road Project YouTube Channel playlist of 700 videos in many categories at;
Or, type in "A Green Road" in the www.Youtube.com search box to see videos available. You will be able to browse one of the largest selections of creative commons licensed videos available on Youtube.
LinkedIn Professionals Network A Green Road Project
LinkedIn Professionals Network A Green Road Project
http://www.linkedin.com/in/agreenroad
Vote For A Green Road Project – help make this a popular website http://www.mywot.com/en/scorecard/www.agreenroadblog.com
Join A Green Road Discussion Group 45,000 + members http://www.care2.com/c2c/group/agreenroad
Vote For A Green Road Project – help make this a popular website http://www.mywot.com/en/scorecard/www.agreenroadblog.com
Join A Green Road Discussion Group 45,000 + members http://www.care2.com/c2c/group/agreenroad
Add Us On Google+
google.com/+AGreenRoadProjectUSA
Best of A Green Road Project On Google Plus
Add A Green Road Project RSS News Feed to your website, blog or news service
http://feeds.feedburner.com/AGreenRoadBlog
What is your score? AGreenRoad Project has a Klout score of 50+ http://klout.com/#/AGreenRoad
Network on MerchantCircle http://member.merchantcircle.com/agreenroad
Read A Green Road Project Feed Burner Syndication FeedBurner makes it easy to receive content updates in My Yahoo!, Newsgator, Bloglines, and other news readers
A Green Road Project Events; http://www.eventbrite.com/myprofile/?oid=4777791053..
What is your score? AGreenRoad Project has a Klout score of 50+ http://klout.com/#/AGreenRoad
Network on MerchantCircle http://member.merchantcircle.com/agreenroad
Read A Green Road Project Feed Burner Syndication FeedBurner makes it easy to receive content updates in My Yahoo!, Newsgator, Bloglines, and other news readers
A Green Road Project Events; http://www.eventbrite.com/myprofile/?oid=4777791053..
Post a Comment